rigel: (apollo omg)

Romance Review: "Whitney, My Love" by Judith McNaught

Time for another "classic" from my collection!

This, dear friends, is the very first romance book I ever read. It made a rather remarkable impression on my tender 12 year old mind and ever since I have harbored a passion to marry a titled man, so that I too can be addressed as "your Grace."

I have to confess - I LOVE THIS BOOK. Love it, read it once a year at least - but I can admit it has flaws - oh yes... dubious... very dubious...

Firstly the Cover! Is there manboob?

They don't make covers like they used to! These days it's all tasteful pictures of flowers or manor houses done in hazy pastels. If you're lucky you might get what's known as a "stepback" cover where the racy picture is hidden on the inside.

Witness the current boringness: A tree, erm and yes... some wildflowers. How compelling...

I've had to scan my own copy (which is literally falling to pieces - note the sticky tape!)
Here be the cover:



Note our titular heroine, with uplifted gaze (green eyes!!) and loose flowing seductive hair (is there a wind machine in the background?)

Then we notice the couple below, with our hero (more on him later) attempting to get a leg over... (that - can't be a comfortable position) distinct manboob shadowing there, only just offset by Whitney's own heaving bosom.

But wait! This is a full blown cover - with awesomeness extending to the back, and here is why I loved this book:



*melts* The soulful staring hawt hero man! with bonus carrying-off-of-heroine-on-white-stallion-of-girlish-dreams.

Yes! you too are enthralled by such a cover and can't wait to dive in to experience the promised awesome!

Our Heroine: Hoyden, High Spirited, Scandal-Waiting-To-Happen - SEND HER TO FRANCE!

Miss Whitney Stone
Age - 15
Favourite Pastimes: Standing up on horses backs, pursuing neighborhood swain, wearing breeches, reading the classics (in the original Greek!)
Appearance: Pretty (but not too pretty) Dirty from all the riding around making a spectacle of herself.

Poor Daddy is beside himself (Mama being conveniently dead) and has enlisted the help of his erstwhile sister-in-law and her husband (who, also conveniently, has been recently posted to France as a diplomat)

Pity no-one informed Whitney...

We have heartbroken tears "Oh Papa, do you really hate me that much that you need me out of your sight?" and a plea of "Will you wait for me" to local swain who she very much loves Paul Sevarin who views her as a rather annoying chit, and is set on pursuing local beauty Elizabeth Ashton.

Cue farewell scene where Whitney vows to herself to return and marry him, gazing at the fading cliffs of Dover - "lately... the toast of Paris!"

He came to a masquerade dressed as the devil himself, how very appropriate!

Fast forward four years. Young Whitney has blossomed into a "true beauty" and has taken Paris by storm with her quick wit and style with the help of BFF's brother, the devastatingly handsome Nicholas Du'Ville.

Handsome, urbane, a trifle jaded - he is the perfect foil - but we all know not the hero - oh no... we meet him at a ball. A masquerade.

He identifies her costume as "Proserpine" (*gasp* he is educated unlike all the others who think she is Venus) And in the course of one conversation in which she mocks the idea that he could be a Duke in disguise, she has thoroughly bewitched him.

Meet Clayton Westmoreland - Duke of Claymore

35, devastatingly handsome, obscenely rich, bored with his current mistress and on the lookout for a wife.

What do you mean you sold me?

Of course Westmorland is a Duke, and hence the rules don't apply to him. He can't be bothered with courtship and all that...

Oh yes! He instructs his lawyer to bail out Daddy's debt (to the tune of 10,000 pounds) and have dear Whitney recalled to England poste haste where he can woo her at his leisure (woo of course being purely for her benefit - can't have a frigid wife after all!)

(and let's not mention that whole "bought her" thing ok?)

Our Whitney is overjoyed! She's going home and can finally put into action her masterplan to catch local swain Paul!

Our Hero has bought himself the neighbouring estate and is styling himself as Mr. Westland - because he can't have her want to marry him for his title! He wants her willing and in lurve and he has no doubts about his abilities to pull it off.

So we have Whitney (ha bitches, I'm beautiful and successful now!) being pursued by Mr Westland (really a Duke) throwing herself at Paul (penniless, ears pricked up now that there seems to be more money in the Stone household) and being pushed by her daddy to see Westland in a romantic light.

We have passionate kissage (OMG! I love Paul, but how can I feel this for another man!) and Clayton actually falling for her (awwww :P)

But then... da da dun!!!

All is revealed!

Cue massive angst and "How could you Daddy????"

OMGWTFBBQ... I didn't just read that

So here I'm skipping ahead :D We've had:

"I just need some time to get used to the idea so let's not announce our engagement to the whole wide world (and in the meantime I'll plot with Paul to elope)"

"No Paul, I have no dowry, that was just money that my Daddy got paid for selling me. OMG you never loved me in the first place it was just the money!!"

"Wow, I really love the Duke after all."

"Duke finds out about plot to elope and takes it all the wrong way, oh and Paul (evil evil man) implies that the reason she was sent to France is because she was a "loose" woman all along"

So, here's the EXTREME DODGINESS!

Westmoreland is all enraged, thinking that she's been a slut all along and toying with his affections. Well he's darn well going to enjoy what he's bought and paid for... Drags her off from a ball back to his townhouse and proceeds to rape seduce her.

Oh and realises she was a virgin, is horrified at what he's done, runs away crying like a big baby releases her from the engagement and generally behaves like a doofus.

And we're only half way through folks! Here are some highlights from the remainder:

* A series of "misunderstandings" culminating in Whitney high-ing herself over to his mother's house to beg him to love her again. - Seriously she BEGS him!!!!!!!!!

* I shall befriend you, my former rival!

* That's not my baby you're carrying!

The melodrama!! *dies from it*

Next up: "Something Wonderful" by the same author aka "Mary Wonder-Sue and the Duke who needs to understand the meaning behind the 'smell of dirt'"

Comments

So I totally need to read this now.

Although explain to me? Why the hell would he release her from the engagement if he just discovered she wasn't lying? I'm confused by the melodrama?
Yes, yes you do!

Judith McNaught is one of the biggest romance names and all of her books are completely ludicrous but hugely readable :D

And he's all ashamed and Woe! I am the worst man in the history of evar and am not worthy of her love.

(also known as the plot-device-of-doom)
methinks not so much plot device of doom as 'stupid male ego' heh.
Oh that is just brilliant! The original cover is far superior the Tree of Boringness - what were they thinking of when they decided to go with that instead? You do such a wonderful job of these - I've now read the entire book in under ten minutes!
Indeed!

If I'm reading trashy romance, I like having an overblown male model on the cover with rippling muscles and conveniently open shirts :P

Do you get covers over there with painted pictures of Fabio on them?
Oh yes!

I think I have at least 6 books I can think of off the top of my head with him in a starring role :D

I think my favorite is the naked viking warrior look with the woman worshipping his crotch.

I may have to scan that one :P
That looks like a thing of great loveliness. Ever read the Angelique books by Sergeanne Golon? Angelique (green-eyed, of course) progressed, over a long series of books, through stable boys, evil cousins, marriages of convenience that end in True Love, destitution and poverty and two young children oh woe, King of the Thieves, owning a chocolate shop (!), court intrigue, kings, rape, sultans, eunuchs, pirates, resurrection of True Love, puritans, Native Americans, she-devils... It's a one-stop shop for every romantic cliche ever. I adore the books. Also they have great covers of much hilarity.
I own them! Angelique and the Sultan is perhaps my favourite :P

Yes!! I should totally do the Angelique books!! They hit every single cliche out there :D

But I HAVE to do "Warrior Woman" by Johanna Lindsay first :P
That one has to be seen to be believed!
Hoorah! Yay, you must do Angelique, I'd love to hear your funny take on 'em. I have several lovely, lurid copies, if you want any covers scanned. I learnt a lot of my history from the Angelique books. *g* I think my favourite is Angelique In Love, where she's on the ship with 'Rescator'.
You have covers!!

I picked all mine up in hardcover and they had lost their dustjackets by that time sadly :D
Some of mine have covers. Angelique In Love is in several pieces. If I ever remember, and if I see it in a charity shop, I'll get a 'new' copy. They used to be in charity shops all the time, but I don't remember seeing them in recent years.

Found this yesterday, it has a huge collection of Angelique cover scans. They very funny. http://monteloup.free.fr/
OMG, that was so awesome! If you didn't have this flocked, I'd be reccing it all over the place. HEEE! It follows the formula so WELL! You could do a series of these! :D

Yes! Like pepper_field mentions above, there's so many different fantasies. Sheiks and Native American chiefs and Pirate captains and Lords and Rogues and haa!
And they're all in Angelique. All the historical ones, anyhow. *nods emphatically*

*remembers quote from book jacket* "Far too many men desire you... But you belong to me, and ME ALONE!"

/pimpage.
oooh and "Let me take you," he pleaded. "Try to understand. I'm ravenous, dying of longing for you."

That Angelique has it all!

PIRATES!!! so many pirates!!
Angelique lives enough for about six women. One of the later books mentioned her age as being thirty-something, and I was somewhat incredulous.
That could be, like, from any romance novel EVER.
:D

I have shelves and shelves of romance books (it's my supa sekrit obsession totally normal hobby *cough* tis all about the porn *cough*)

And you may have missed my "Price of Innocence" (http://linnet-101.livejournal.com/72659.html) sporking from last month :P I'll definitely do some more - the world must know about trashy romance!!

Is it flocked? *unflocks it*
I just noticed book jacket quote from your clicky:

"As their elegant travelling chaise rocked and swayed along the rutted country road, Lady Anne Gilbert leaned her cheek against her husband's shoulder and heaved..."

What a place to stop. *g*
"... a long impatient sigh"

sadly no quivering bosom :P
I was thinking more that she was suffering motion sickness from the rocking and swaying of the carriage. But that's my brain for you. *g*
Duke finds out about plot to elope and takes it all the wrong way

... because there's a right way to take that :D

This is much fun - please to be continuing with the romance reviews.

__

Also, and on a totally unrelated note, are you still up for beta'ing the H/D of sort-of-epic-ness? If so, could you send me your email? Mine's on my profile page, viewable by my flist.
oooh of course! *sneds away*

And yes, who would have thought he would get all pouty and annoyed at his fiancee attempting to run off with the local swain! :D
Er... email?
Ha! That's fabulous.

Do you read the Smart Bitches Who Love Trashy Novels (http://www.smartbitchestrashybooks.com/index.php) blog? They do great man-boob cover snark.
Oh wow...

I actually own quite a few of those covers!!

*glees* *bookmarks blog immediately*
Laughing hysterically because really - that book rocked! And I think there is a "sequel" too but the heroine has brown hair. The author manages to hit every single cliche but instead of rolling my eyes, I giggle and reach for another mental cookie.

But I think my all time favorite romance novels were the Velvet series by Jude Deaverux. Read them in high school and still check them out of the library when the world just sucks.
OMG!! I absolutely loved those!! I have them too - and the Peregrine novels which I also have to review :D

I loves me a good medieval-esque knights and ladies romp!

Romance novels are most definitely brain candy.
buwhahaha. Too awesome for words. You are totally bringing back for my my first romance novel I read at like 12 or something. I think it was a Joanna Lindsey book and it had a big purple cover and was a futuristic romance where the advanced woman (she has like some sapce ship that talks to her and stuff) ends up captive to an honorable barbarian.

You are just too funny. Thank you for this, hope to see more!!
I think I have that one! On my shelf!

And the ship is actually programmed to 'pleasure' people, but the heroine would rather be disciplined by the hero!
Hello! I came here through a friend of a friend (actually, I honestly can't even remember how I got here), but this is the best review eva! And I shall now celebrate by digging out some old romance novels and weeping myself silly.

Thanks ever so :D
Yay!!

I romances are fabulous for giving you a good laugh when you need it.

I'm slowly reviewing some of the more WTF books from my collection, the'll all be tagged as romance novel (http://linnet-101.livejournal.com/tag/romance+novel)
Ya know, just for the promptness of reply and the promise of future romance reviews, I do hope you don't mind if I friend you. Like, now :)
OMG! An Aussie! G'day!
Eeee! More Aussies!

*immediately friends back*
Ooh, does this mean I get to see the super!sekrit stuff? Cool!